On Thursday 21 May 2026, Pope Leo addressed 200 leaders of international Catholic lay movements, associations and communities in the Vatican’s Synod Hall. It was an excellent speech in which he addressed issues of governance that affect lay organisations:
https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/speeches/2026/may/documents/20260521-moderatori.html
Well, it’s a good thing that lay leaders meet in Rome to hear the pope speak and it’s great that the pontiff makes time in his schedule to speak to them.
What struck me, however, was the contrast between photographs of this event and so many photos of the Synod on Synodality that took place at the Vatican only a couple of years ago.
Compare and contrast
Let’s look at photos from each.
These are photos on the Vatican News website from this month’s meeting with lay leaders:


And now here are a couple of photos from the Synod:


Notice the difference. The Synod, which is essentially a meeting of bishops even if lay people were invited and also granted the right to vote, was organised as a meeting of equals in “conversation.” Indeed, words like “listening” and “conversation” became leitmotifs of the Synod on Synodality. (But, as I have noted previously, very few leaders of lay organisations or movements were invited to participate.)
Two years later, if the photos of this month’s meeting of lay leaders with Pope Leo are any indication, the Holy See has reverted to type. Not a meeting of equals facilitating conversation but a unidirectional, top down lecture to lay leaders from around the world, whose organisations paid their own way to join the meeting organised and hosted by the Dicastery for Laity, Family and Life.
Now, I am not against Pope Leo delivering a speech or lecture to gathered lay leaders, who, to judge from the photos, greatly appreciated the opportunity to hear him. But where was the meeting of equals of all the “baptised,” the concept so prominent at the Synod on Synodality?
Back to the future
Actually, one reason I was struck by the photos from this month’s meeting of lay leaders with Pope Leo was because it so strongly resembled a similar event that I attended in December 1991 when Pope John Paul II addressed a gathering of the leaders of International Catholic Organisations.
Here’s the speech that John Paul II delivered, sadly only available in French and Italian:
It was a very good speech in which he even quoted Cardijn (my translation):
You are “on the front lines,” as Cardinal Cardijn put it, witnessing the poverty of the people and proposing long-term strategies and projects addressed to political and economic decision-makers. Decisions made nolw need to prepare a habitable world with acceptable living conditions for future generations. In working for this, you are contributing to the royal mission of the Church.
However, that was not what struck me in 1991 while listening to John Paul. Rather it was the fact that gathered in the meeting hall were roughly 200 leaders of international Catholic organisations with vast experience of every imaginable field of human and Christian endeavour.
Yet there was no opportunity for any of them to share any of that with the pontiff. Indeed, apart from listening to his speech, our only contact with him was to line up and shake his hand.
And, in what appeared to me then and even more now as symbolic of that whole encounter, Pope John Paul II was already looking at the person behind me when he shook my hand!
Frankly, I don’t blame him. How many hands can you shake in one session let alone a day? Indeed, what was the actual meaning of such a handshake beyond the staged photo (that official and exclusive Vatican photographers charged exorbitantly for)?
Well, that was 1991. It was bad enough then. How is it still possible in a Church that claims to want to be synodal that this is still the way in which elected lay leaders from around the world get to meet the pope?
In his talk, Pope Leo emphasised the importance of “free elections” in choosing the leadership of international Catholic lay organisations. These elections were “an expression of common discernment: allowing everyone’s voice to be freely expressed,” Pope Leo noted.
I would dare suggest that most of those present to listen to him had indeed been elected to their positions – and sponsored by their own organisations to travel to Rome? So I wonder why the Dicastery for Laity, Family and Life organised such a meeting without providing for the voices of those international leader – most of whom have incredible grassroots experience from around the world – to be expressed to and LISTENED to by the pope.
In a synodal Church emphasing equality, conversation and dialogue, shaking hands with the pontiff and listening one-sidedly to his talk doesn’t cut it anymore.
A year into his pontificate, Leo still has the opportunity to change this.
Stefan Gigacz
