The proposed changes to the Code of Canon put forward by the canon law commission of the Synod on Synodality have now been published. Here are a few, brief initial comments.
The document, which was drafted by the Synod’s Canonical Commission, is available for download here:
And here’s the Vatican News report:
Positive changes
There are a number of proposed changes that recognise or provide for a greater role of lay people in filling official Church positions.
Thus, the proposed new Canon 496 §2 provides that “episcopal delegates” may be “chosen from among the Christian faithful deemed suitable,” i.e. including from among suitable lay people.
The proposed new Canon 1421 enables lay people as well as clergy to become judges in canon law courts.
The proposed Canon 511 makes pastoral councils mandatory rather than simply based on “pastoral circumstances.”
Synods must now be held every ten years.
Proposed Canon 440 also provides that provincial councils must be held every ten years.
The draft new Canon 461 – § 1 states that a “diocesan synod is to be celebrated in individual particular churches at least every ten years so that its members, through a common discernment, consider well-defined and specific issues, periodically verify the implementation of the pastoral plan of the diocese, and propose a new plan for the future.”
Moreover, major superiors of religious institutes and societies of apostolic life must be invited to attend councils, and their representatives are to be elected by their peers (Draft Canon 443 – § 3).
Where are the lay ecclesial movements?
But, you guessed it, no mention of lay movements anywhere!
This despite the fact that the Synod on Synodality Final Document §65 explicitly says:
Orders and congregations, societies of apostolic life, secular institutes, as well as associations, movements and new communities, all have a special contribution to make to the growth of synodality in the Church…. At the same time, synodality invites – and sometimes challenges – pastors of local Churches, as well as those responsible for leadership in consecrated life and in the movements, to strengthen relationships in order to bring
to life an exchange of gifts at the service of the common mission.
Further §118 states:
We recognise that institutes of consecrated life, societies of apostolic life, as well as associations, movements and new communities, have the ability to take root locally and, at the same time, connect different places and milieus, often at a national or international level. Their action, together with that of many individuals and informal groups, often brings the Gospel to highly diverse contexts: to hospitals, prisons, homes for the elderly, reception centres for migrants, minors, those marginalised and victims of violence; to centres of education and training, schools and universities where young people and families meet; to the arenas of culture and politics and of integral human development, where new forms of living together are imagined and constructed… Institutes and associations are called to act in synergy with the local Church, participating in the dynamism of synodality.
So, how is this supposed to happen if the said movements are not involved or invited to participate in provincial or particular councils, synods or pastoral councils?
Every mention of “the faithful” or lay people is on an individual, selected basis.
Ecclesial movements and communities simply do not exist as far as the proposed changes go.
The Canonical Commission report does not say this explicitly but in effect ecclesial movements and communities are treated as belonging to the Church’s private sphere rather than the public sphere.
The concept of an autonomous lay movement with a public mandate from the Church does not exist.
In this context, I keep coming back, as I often do, to §26 of the Vatican II Decree on the Apostolate of the Laity, Apostolicam Actuositatem (AA):
26. In dioceses, insofar as possible, there should be councils which assist the apostolic work of the Church either in the field of evangelization and sanctification or in the charitable, social, or other spheres, and here it is fitting that the clergy and Religious should cooperate with the laity. While preserving the proper character and autonomy of each organization, these councils will be able to promote the mutual coordination of various lay associations and enterprises.
Councils of this type should be established as far as possible also on the parochial, interparochial, and interdiocesan level as well as in the national or international sphere.
True, AA does not specifically say that such movements will be part of those councils but it more than implies that they should be involved.
What’s more, if you look further at what AA §26 says about the international level, it does call for the participation of movements in what is now the Dicastery for Laity:
The various movements and projects of the apostolate of the laity throughout the world should also be represented in this secretariat, and here clergy and Religious also are to cooperate with the laity.
But, once again, as I have pointed out many times, including in relation to the Study Group 6 report, the Dicastery has not implemented this requirement.
And it seems clear to me that the Synodal canon law commission has not adverted to AA §26 either.
The good news is that these proposed changes have not yet been formalised in canon law so there’s still time to make representations on these issues to ensure a greater role for lay people and the representatives of lay ecclesial movements.
Stefan Gigacz
